Flashback Friday: Vernon Wells’ Walk-Off Home Run Against Mariano Rivera

Mariano Rivera will wrap up his career at season’s end as the greatest closer of all time. A surefire Hall of Famer, Rivera’s career stands as the very best among relief pitchers.

Mariano Rivera has made a career of cutting up the Toronto Blue Jays; 54 career saves, a 1.81 lifetime ERA, and 107 strikeouts in 104.1 career innings versus the Blue Jays.

Over the course of his career, Mariano Rivera’s mistakes have been few and far between. For the most part, he’s been untouchable. But there are select few who have gotten the better of the Yankees closer on the rare occasion.


One of them just so happens to be a former Toronto Blue Jay and Rivera’s current teammate, Vernon Wells. For this week’s Flashback Friday, we take a look back at Vernon Wells’ walk-off home run off Mariano Rivera.

Let’s set the stage; it’s July 20, 2006. The Yankees and Blue Jays are very much in the thick of the Wild Card hunt, with Toronto trailing New York by four games in the standings. And 42,336 fans were there to witness history that day at the Rogers Centre.

Both Roy Halladay and Mike Mussina started the game and posted solid efforts as they handed things over to the bullpen in the eighth inning. Although Toronto held a slim 4-3 lead, John Gibbons elected to bring in his closer B.J. Ryan to face the middle of the Yankees order in the top of the 8th.

However, the move backfired as the Yankees tied the game and it eventually went into extra innings. Joe Torre subsequently brought in his closer Mariano Rivera in the 10th inning, and he retired the side and came back to pitch the 11th.

Apparently, Torre flew a little too close to the sun in asking his closer to get six outs. Frank Catalanotto led off the 11th by reaching base via a single, but he was promptly thrown out the very next pitch trying to steal second base.

So with the bases clear, Vernon Wells came to the plate, and he made history.

Vernon Wells cranked Mariano Rivera’s signature cutter to left field for a walk-off home run, and in doing so the Blue Jays accomplished the unthinkable; they slayed the dragon that was Mariano Rivera.

According to Baseball Reference, Wells’ walk-off home run was just one of five regular season walk-off home runs surrendered by Mariano Rivera in his entire career.


Date Batter @Bat Score Inn Out RoB Pit(cnt)Sequence bWPA Notes
2002-07-14 Bill Selby CLE behind 6-7 b 9 2 123 6,(2-2) BBCFFX 72% Walk-Off
2004-07-24 Bill Mueller BOS behind 9-10 b 9 1 1– 5,(3-1) .BCBBX 76% Walk-Off
2006-07-20 Vernon Wells TOR tied 4-4 b 11 1 2,(1-0) >B.X 41% Walk-Off
2007-04-15 Marco Scutaro OAK behind 2-4 b 9 2 12- 3,(0-2) CFX 91% Walk-Off
2009-09-18 Ichiro Suzuki SEA behind 1-2 b 9 2 -2- 1,(0-0) .X 86% Walk-Off

Only four Blue Jays have ever hit home runs off Mariano Rivera: Mike Stanley, Ed Sprague, the aforementioned Vernon Wells, and Edwin Encarnacion.

And the timing of Wells’ walk-off home run could not have been better for the Blue Jays; as they were amid the Shea Hillenbrand controversy and had just designated him for assignment the day prior.

The walk-off home run was one of the more memorable moments of Vernon Wells tumultuous career in Toronto. The one thing I’ll never forget is the image above of him rounding first base with his fist in the air in celebration.

Vernon Wells may not have got a chance to play in the playoffs during his time with the Blue Jays, but at least he hit a walk-off home run off Mariano Rivera. And depending on who you ask, that might be just as good.

Hat tip to Ian Denomme from Yahoo! Sports for the inspiration for this week’s Flashback Friday post. Check out his piece on Wells walk-off home run.

Ian Hunter

Ian has been writing about the Toronto Blue Jays since 2007. He enjoyed the tail-end of the Roy Halladay era and vividly remembers the Alex Rodriguez "mine" incident. He'll also retell the story of Game 5 of the 2015 ALDS to his kids for the next 20 years.

2 thoughts on “Flashback Friday: Vernon Wells’ Walk-Off Home Run Against Mariano Rivera

  • September 20, 2013 at 6:05 pm

    The Blue Jays didn't release Shea Hillenbrand he was Traded by the Toronto Blue Jays with Vinnie Chulk to the San Francisco Giants for Jeremy Accardo.

    • September 20, 2013 at 9:04 pm

      Made the correction … looks like he was DFA's and then traded.

Comments are closed.