How Much is Draft Pick Compensation Costing Bautista & Encarnacion?

It’s no coincidence that the three biggest remaining free agents all have a common thread. Jose Bautista, Edwin Encarnacion and Mark Trumbo are all tied to a draft pick … and it’s weighing them down this offseason.

Although the qualifying offer/draft pick compensation clause will cease to exist next year, it’s certainly had an impact on how prospective teams approach free agents who have draft pick compensation associated with them.

For Bautista, Encarnacion and Trumbo, being associated with draft pick compensation is hindering their chances of getting an offer from a new team.


I heard an interesting bit on the FanGraphs podcast a few weeks ago; Dave Cameron said something to the effect of a draft pick being worth somewhere in the $10 million range; evidence that teams covet draft picks  now more than ever.

The Blue Jays know first-hand just how valuable those late first round picks can become. Just look at Aaron Sanchez (47th overall pick in 2010) and Marcus Stroman (29th overall pick in 2012); two players drafted via compensatory picks. In this era of baseball, prospects are like gold.

Prospective teams must not only factor in the cost of signing a Bautista, Encarnacion or Trumbo, they also must factor in the cost of losing a draft pick; which is in the neighbourhood of $10 million. Cameron described it as a “draft pick tax”.

Which means a potential two-year/$30 million deal for Jose Bautista suddenly looks like a two-year/$40 million deal in total. A four-year/$90 million deal for Edwin Encarnacion creeps up to $100 million.

It’s debatable whether draft pick compensation is significantly hindering Edwin Encarnacion’s chances. If teams are in contention and looking for right-handed power, there’s no better option on the market than Encarnacion. He’s certainly worth handing over a draft pick.

However, it’s a much different case for Jose Bautista. He picked the absolute worst time to have a down year. Not only are teams questioning Bautista’s viability as an everyday outfielder, but at 36 years old and coming off two DL stints this past season, injuries are also a concern. On top of that, the draft pick compensation is looming large over Jose Bautista’s head.

That’s precisely why it’s always made the most sense for Jose Bautista to return to the Toronto Blue Jays on a short-term deal. If he’s willing to sign a one or two-year contract with an opt-out clause, Bautista has the potential to build his value in 2017 and he’ll no longer be associated with a draft pick.

However, by signing Jose Bautista, the Blue Jays don’t “surrender” a draft pick, but they preclude themselves from getting one from another team. If Bautista goes elsewhere, the Blue Jays will get a pick (regardless of whether it’s a team with a protected pick or not).

Not only have Jose Bautista and Edwin Encarnacion been affected by the draft pick compensation, but the CBA negotiations also likely had an impact on any traction Edwin Encarnacion (and to a lesser extent, Jose Bautista) had gained leading up to the Winter Meetings.


The CBA took precedence and most contract talks took a back burner. Meanwhile, free agents like Edwin Encarancion lost precious time to speak with potential suitors.

Ultimately, I find it very difficult to see a team without a protected pick going after Jose Bautista. He’s already a wild card as is; being tied to a draft pick makes Jose Bautista even more of a risk.

Based purely off their age and their most recent results, Edwin Encarnacion is the safer bet of the two players. Encarnacion has yet to experience a decline. Jose Bautista arguably already has.

Both guys can still provide a great deal of production relative to their cost. Will teams value that big league production more than the upside of a first round draft pick? That is what will determine where Bautista and Encarnacion end of this offseason.

Ian Hunter

Ian has been writing about the Toronto Blue Jays since 2007. He enjoyed the tail-end of the Roy Halladay era and vividly remembers the Alex Rodriguez "mine" incident. He'll also retell the story of Game 5 of the 2015 ALDS to his kids for the next 20 years.

One thought on “How Much is Draft Pick Compensation Costing Bautista & Encarnacion?

  • December 13, 2016 at 9:30 am

    But EE did decline a bit last year. He was healthy all year so his totals were up. He signed a 3+1 extension in 2012. But since then, 2016 was his worst season for many of his rate stats: K%, Slugging, wRC+, average… I think teams are being a bit careful


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *