Do the Blue Jays Have A Legitimate Chance of Re-Signing David Price?

Call me crazy, call me delusional … but I think the Blue Jays have a real legitimate chance to re-sign David Price this offseason.

Admittedly, it’s way too early to be thinking about 2016 and beyond, but it’s a topic which has been broached by the media and fans alike; could the Toronto Blue Jays table a competitive offer to David Price and bring him back to Toronto long term?

David Price will undoubtedly have plenty of suitors lined up this offseason willing to give him a blank cheque for whatever amount he wants. The scales could very easily skip $200 million dollars and even $250 million dollars for one of the best arms in baseball in David Price.


Surprisingly, the Toronto Blue Jays could be one of those teams, to likely go along with the New York Yankees, the Los Angeles Dodgers and any other big market team. They’ll all be competing for his services, but the Blue Jays just might have the upper hand.

Although the purse strings were fairly tight in 2013, the Blue Jays front office has proven that they’re willing to spend money on the right player. Russell Martin of course being the prime case, as he fetched the largest free agent contract ever signed by a Blue Jays player.

The Blue Jays aren’t in the business of spending money just for the sake of spending money, but as of late, it appears as though there’s been a culture shift towards getting value from the very best players on the market. David Price would certainly fit that description.

Sure, another team like the Yankees or Dodgers could easily surpass any potential offer put forth by the Blue Jays to David Price. But for a player of Price’s calibre at his age, it might be more about the quality of team rather than the quality of contract.

Here’s the strongest indication to me that the Blue Jays have a decent chance at bringing back David Price. And it know it might seem weird and superfluous, but here goes … it’s the scooters and the bathrobes.

It was innocent enough; David Price buys scooters for all his teammates just a few weeks after his arrival in Toronto. Then just last week, Price went and bought customized matching blue bathrobes for the entire roster.

Those were two different ways in which Price wanted to endear himself to his new teammates, and it sounds like the gestures were appreciated all around. To me, these aren’t the kinds of things that “rentals” do; this behaviour is indicative of guys who foresee themselves being with this team beyond the near future.

In reality, David Price is the one who should’ve had a scooter and custom bathrobe awaiting him in his locker on July 31st. Yet here was David Price wanting to prove his worth when he didn’t need to prove his worth to anybody on the Blue Jays roster.

During his tenure with the Blue Jays, Price has really gone out of the way to try to be “one of the guys”, which hints that he may actually be in this for the long haul.


As far as recruiting David Price to re-sign in Toronto, I think the Blue Jays have already presented their case as to why he should come back. Just look back at his very first start as a Blue Jay on Civic Monday and the unbridled passion from the fans not only that day, but every subsequent home game after.

David Price spoke at great lengths about how he was blown away by the reaction of the fans, and with six weeks under his belt as a Blue Jay, I think the team’s case is only getting better as the season progresses.

While he was fairly anonymous in Tampa Bay and was part of a better supporting cast in Detroit, David Price is a rockstar in Toronto. Ever since his arrival to the Blue Jays, he’s been regarded as a saviour for this franchise. Price is so well-liked in Toronto that he may not want to leave this environment come season’s end.

Even Alex Anthopoulos thinks the Blue Jays have a leg up on the competition now that David Price has experienced what Toronto is like as an organization and as a city.

Anthopoulos spoke to Prime Time Sports last week about the prospect of re-signing Price, and he was actually quite optimistic.

“I would think our chances have only improved since he’s been here.

I’ve been here long enough that we try to recruit players and bring them to Toronto and try to tell them what it’s like, and what the travel is like, what the team is like and what the clubhouse is like.

We don’t have to do any of that now. He knows exactly what it’s like to live in the city during the season.

What the fan base is like, what the environment is like and the support staff … he has all those questions answered. And there’s an advantage to that.

With elite players like Price, he doesn’t need more teams to be in the mix for him. It’s going to come down to where he wants to play. Just to hopefully be in the conversation because he likes where he is and he likes what he’s seen and been around, that’s a big part of it as well.

I think we’ve only helped ourselves, the fact that he’s been able to spend two to three months here.”

This is the the distinct advantage the Blue Jays have over any other potential suitor for David Price (save for Tampa Bay and Detroit); Price gets to take a two-month long test drive of the Toronto Blue Jays organization before hitting free agency.


The thing to remember here is depending on how far the Blue Jays take things this year, David Price could see himself as a pivotal figure on a very successful Blue Jays team; one that is not only built to win this year, but is also set up to be competitive in the near future as well.

Much like Robinson Cano signed long term in Seattle and the Chicago Cubs locked up Jon Lester long term, I think for players, there’s definitely an appeal of going to another team and helping establish a winning franchise. If David Price could do that in Toronto with the Blue Jays, he would be revered until no end.

From the Blue Jays’ perspective, the desire to have David Price return is very strong. Even with a healthy Marcus Stroman returning next season, the Blue Jays’ starting rotation picture looks very hazy.

Since Mark Buehrle and Marco Estrada are free agents at season’s end, take your pick from R.A. Dickey, Aaron Sanchez and Drew Hutchison. Even with Marcus Stroman, there’s quite a bit of room for improvement in the Blue Jays’ starting five.

Remember, pitchers like David Price don’t come around very often and this offseason could the Blue Jays’ rare opportunity to lock up a pitcher of his calibre to a long-term contract.

I won’t argue the pitfalls of signing long-term contracts to starting pitchers on the other side of 30. It’s a risky proposition, but as with any signing or trade, there is inherent risk; you get the production up front and eventually pay for it on the back end of the contract.

Perhaps with Mark Shapiro taking over as team president, the universally panned “five year policy” can officially finally be abolished; which in turn, can help make the Blue Jays a serious player for big name free agents like David Price.

Even at upwards of $250 million dollars, many teams would say that David Price will be worth every single penny. And the Blue Jays have already made a strong case for Price to re-sign with Toronto.

If the money is truly there for top tier free agents, the Blue Jays may have already laid the framework for a potential David Price return.

Image via Sarah Crabill/Getty Images

Ian Hunter

Ian has been writing about the Toronto Blue Jays since 2007. He enjoyed the tail-end of the Roy Halladay era and vividly remembers the Alex Rodriguez "mine" incident. He'll also retell the story of Game 5 of the 2015 ALDS to his kids for the next 20 years.

12 thoughts on “Do the Blue Jays Have A Legitimate Chance of Re-Signing David Price?

  • September 17, 2015 at 1:47 pm

    The mega-contract sure makes it look unlikely, but as you pointed out, there's a few reasons to believe there's a chance. Not least of which the Jays will need at least another body for the rotation next season. Another couple things I'd add:

    – Price won't cost a draft pick, which I think the Jays might value after skipping the 1st round this year
    – I believe dropping this cash on Price means it'll be unlikely they extend Bautista & EE. With Tulo, Martin, Donaldson & then Price, there's a ton of $$ commitment (tho a good core). I think it's hard to see JB & EE fit on top of that.
    – Because of the reasons you presented above, Price might be the player the Jays should go after. Great free agent pitchers are tough to lure to Toronto. Don't think the Jays could just as easily lure Greinke or Zimmerman or Cueto.

  • September 17, 2015 at 2:55 pm

    I'm not so pessimistic about Bautista and Encarancion.

    First, I don't think they want to leave. The moves AA made this season has probably squashed Bautista's grumbling, and EE strikes me as the kind of guy that's in a comfort zone and is content to stay.

    Second, I don't think extending them would cost much more. If the Jays can afford them now, they can afford a 20% hike for them.

    Third, they both have options for 2016. Surely if AA is willing to extend them now (and not wait to negotiate during the 2016 season), that will earn AA some goodwill that will make the 20% hike acceptable as a "hometown" discount.

    Fourth, not resigning Buehrle frees-up money, as does not picking-up Dickey's 2016 option. Couple that with sold-out games at Rogers Centre, and giving Price the keys to the kingdom doesn't mean it all comes out of Bautista and EE's future pocket.

    • September 17, 2015 at 5:21 pm

      Don't you want to pick up Dickey's option? Even if Price re-ups the Jays rotation would be Price, Stroman, ??, ??, Hutchison… and with the departure of Hoffman, Norris, and Boyd the Jays have precisely zero mlb ready pre-arb guys to step into the rotation to fill those ?? spots. I'm sure some would say "Sanchez and Osuna" but I think Sanchez is a bullpen arm given all the evidence and who knows about Osuna.

      Dickey may not be what we thought we were getting when we traded for him but his deal is still at least fair (albeit not surplus) value for the dollars that he'll make.

  • September 17, 2015 at 4:13 pm

    Great article but I wish bloggers would stop using the "…other side of 30" arguement. He just turned 30 a month ago..less even. Does that mean if we signed him 2 weeks before his birthday things would be fine? Nit picky but at this point his age isn't an issue. As for JB and EE…I think if the Jays go far this the first round at a minimum that will be a positive when it comes to negotiations. That being said these guys are in line for major raises and we have to hope that a light truly went on at Rogers. Put the money into the team..keep it competitive and the attendence as well as related revenues will rise. Toronto is a huge market..Rogers should act accordingly. But its Rogers…need I say more…thanks again for a great read Ian.

  • September 17, 2015 at 4:18 pm

    Maybe for once, having corporate overlords owning the team will work in our favor. If every time Price pitches, the ratings for TV and Radio are up for Roger then the revenue they directly generate because of Price is tangible. In the last 3 months Rogers has gotten a taste of the money they can rake in with a winning team and an ace like Price. I only hope the last 3 months have opened the eyes at the fucktards at Rogers. Even expanding the payroll to $180M with the exchange rate as it is, if the Jays are winning and drawing in 200K fans on tv and selling out the dome, then its a licence to print money for Rogers. You could give Price $32M a year and you probably make that in advertising revenue just for tv ad revenue in the games that he pitches. Ratings for the Jays is nuts and that drives soooooo much revenue. Look how much Rogers paid for the NHL contract for 12 years. The Jays are drawing better then the NHL. I agree that i easily see the Jays signing Price and dropping $250M on him knowing that they'll make that just in ad revenue for his starts.

  • September 17, 2015 at 4:43 pm

    Uh… You heavily forgot the CUBS in this Price race–with Joe Maddon, especially. Further, the yearly money won't be as big a issue as one might think per year. Why?… (Well, at least in the FRONT end of any David Price deal): Buehrle's 20 million will come off the books, along with Navarro's 6 million. Not to mention the waste of money on Romero finally ending. That alone makes up–or nearly so–the salary Price would command. Not to mention the Jays could draw 3.6 million fans or more next season–increasing their revenues greatly. Those reasons give Toronto fans hope. That said, they will have to compensate Price for the higher Canadian tax rates with an increased salary–along… yes, along–with needing to extend Bautista and EE two more seasons.

    • September 17, 2015 at 5:58 pm

      Take a hard look…Tax Rates are not really an issues except in States.that have no income tax. Many studies out there that disprove the whole tax rate thing.

    • September 19, 2015 at 1:58 am

      Price has stated a few times that his decision won't be based on the Manager, when reporters have brought up Maddon. Same as the GM, when the Boston media asked him about to Boston with Dombrowski.

  • September 19, 2015 at 1:21 pm

    Honestly, I think one of the most compelling reasons for Price to stay was evidenced in his last start. Defence. When you have talented and smart fielders behind you your numbers and results very a lot better.

    Price pitched a good game, but if Donaldson, Smoak, and Goins aren't making diving catches, and if Pennington isn't alert on that missed-pop-turned-into-double-play then Price is probably giving up a couple more runs.

  • September 23, 2015 at 5:36 am

    At the end of the day, money and a competitive team is going to get Price.
    He is going to get money no matter what, but another year at least of Mount Crushmore, coupled with a roster that is going to be together at the start of the year (save for Buerhle, I think Estrada gets a solid raise and resigns), this is a potential 100 win world series contending team for the next few years

  • September 23, 2015 at 5:42 am

    At the end of the day, money and a competitive team is going to get Price.
    He is going to get money no matter what, but another year at least of Mount Crushmore, coupled with a roster that is going to be together at the start of the year (save for Buerhle, I think Estrada gets a solid raise and resigns), this is a potential 100 win world series contending team for the next few years

  • October 6, 2015 at 2:02 pm

    I would hope the Jays sign Price for a long term but my feeling is that Jays will not pony up that much cash for him. Other teams like the Yankees, Boston, Dodgers will simply swoop by and take him away under the Jays nose. Without Price I don't see us being competitive for next year. After Stroman, Dickey we have nobody that can step in and pitch. Hutchison should start in the minors he is not an accomplished pitcher.

Comments are closed.