Attention V-Mart shoppers …

Talk about the bombshell that never happened … the Toronto Blue Jays were actually in the market to get Victor Martinez at the trade deadline earlier this year?

This was mentioned in passing in a recent article by Rob Bradford from WEEI. If it weren’t from the heads-up from the guys at MLB Trade Rumors, I probably would never have even noticed it.It said that the Blue Jays were planning on keeping Roy Halladay while trading to get Victor Martinez from the Cleveland Indians in hopes they could put together a contender in 2010.

Obviously any preliminary trade talks between the Blue Jays and the Indians must have fallen through the cracks because we’re just hearing about these developments now, but it makes one wonder … what would the Blue Jays have to give up to land Victor Martinez in the first place?
The Red Sox picked him up by sending Justin Masterson along with a couple of Single A prospects in Bryan Price and Nick Hagadone. Masterson was the key to the deal with over 200 innings experience in the majors. The equivalent of this trade for the Blue Jays would probably include a highly-touted prospect from the minor-league system that has big league experience like Brett Cecil or Marc Rzepczynski.
The addition of Victor Martinez would create a log jam at the catching position, so the Jays would have either had to deal Rod Barajas (whose contract expires at then end of the season) or move Martinez over to first base. If the Blue Jays decided to do the latter, then they would have to find a buyer for Lyle Overbay.
Now you can see why the trade talks were dead in the water before things progressed to the next level. For the Blue Jays to acquire Victor Martinez, it would have required the right pieces to fall in to the right place at the right time. Unfortunately, not even one of those variables worked in the favour of the Blue Jays at the trade deadline.

Ian Hunter

Ian has been writing about the Toronto Blue Jays since 2007. He enjoyed the tail-end of the Roy Halladay era and vividly remembers the Alex Rodriguez "mine" incident. He'll also retell the story of Game 5 of the 2015 ALDS to his kids for the next 20 years.

6 thoughts on “Attention V-Mart shoppers …

  • October 9, 2009 at 6:28 pm

    I wonder if J.P. would have stayed on had this deal gone through.

    V-Mart woulda been great with Toronto. A solid catcher, another solid bat.

    Oh, the humanity.

  • October 9, 2009 at 6:40 pm

    V-Mart with the Jays would have went a long way in re-signing Doc too. While I don't think he'll put us over the top, it would have been a good start to 2010. I hope the offseason will be a busy one.

  • October 9, 2009 at 7:10 pm

    We would have won a lot of those one run losses too. Definitely would have dramatically changed the oitcome of the season…

  • October 9, 2009 at 8:13 pm

    eyeB, it's tough to say what would have happened. I have a feeling V-Mart probably wanted to play for a contender, which basically sealed the deal for the Red Sox.

    HLF, that's another factor that I didn't even think about – signing Martinez would probably give more incentive for Halladay to stick it out in Toronto and try to make the playoffs.

    Mattt, I would have loved to see V-Mart with the Jays but I think the Blue Jays would have a tough time fitting him in unless they traded Barajas or Overbay. Rod is probably gone at the end of the year, so the options are looking bleak behind the backstop for the Jays.

  • October 10, 2009 at 12:55 am

    They would have made Barajas the backup and released/demoted Chavez, right? Not a hard decision.

  • October 10, 2009 at 6:22 pm

    Torgen, sometimes the best solutions are the easiest ones (like you suggested). Honestly, I hadn't consider that because I'm not used to the Jays having two power hitters at one position. I would've felt spoiled if the Jays had V-Mart AND Barajas.

Comments are closed.