An Open Letter to Alex Anthopoulos

Dear Alex,

How’s your summer been? Mine’s been alright … a little disappointing, as I’m sure you can understand. That’s not entirely your fault, though.

Anyway, the reason I’m writing today is because I’m a little concerned.


There’s no question things were a mess after the debacle that was last year; the onslaught of injuries, the Escobar eyeblack scandal, and of course the John Farrell situation. Things were not good, but you quickly remedied the situation.

At the onset of the season this scenario seemed unfathomable, but 2013 is shaping up to be even worse than 2012 was.

If you match them up side by side, both seasons are actually pretty similar in both results and even the overall tone, but with one discernible difference; the Blue Jays were supposed to be contenders this year, and clearly they’re not.

Luckily after that trade with the Marlins, most people forgot all about that season from hell. But unfortunately, it was only about 3-4 weeks into the 2013 season when doubt about the Blue Jays crept up once again.

Sure, the team managed to turn things around there in mid-June, but since then it’s like the team has fallen off the cliff. Just like last year, injuries piled up, the starting pitching has been subpar, and the defense hasn’t been the greatest, either.

Again, I’m not saying this is all your fault. But as the General Manager of this team, it’s your job to fix this mess.

You assembled a pretty impressive roster on paper this offseason. Sometimes I still can’t believe my eyes that Jose Reyes is in a Blue Jays uniform, so kudos on that one. But most of the other moves haven’t really panned out so well.

The roster doesn’t need to be completely overhauled, but things need to change. Mostly, the starting rotation. Dickey and Buehrle are essentially the only two who can be penciled into the rotation right now. Needless to say, there’s a lot of work to be done in the pitching department.

I don’t know what you should do about the Josh Johnson thing. You seem to really like the guy, but maybe it’s okay to let him walk at the end of the year.


I guess you have to weigh the options; would you rather have people bellyache over paying Johnson $14.5 million next year, or let him go and watch Josh have a career year with the Yankees?

As we learned the past few years, there is no such thing as having too much starting pitching. But at the same time, don’t just assume Esmil Rogers, Todd Redmond or even Brandon Morrow will be enough to carry the rest of the starting rotation.

The offense needs to be upgraded as well; namely at second base and catcher.  You’ve got to make a decision on what to do with J.P. Arencibia. He may be good with the media (or at least he was), but his primary focus should be on his athletic ability, and not his on-camera charisma.

Arencibia could probably make a strong case in arbitration with all those home runs under his belt, so if you’re going to stick with him, be prepared to shell out a lot of money for his services over the coming years. And also be prepared to deal with the backlash if J.P. continues on this path.

I feel like this offseason is a time where you really need to draw a line in the sand on where you stand with J.P. Arencibia. Either you’re going to unequivocally stand by this guy no matter what and lock him up to a contract, or you need to ship him off this winter. Please end the drama once and for all. 

Second base is going to be a bit trickier; you were probably pretty happy to get Maicer Izturis to that team-friendly contract, but he simply is not going to cut it, either. At the very least, if you can’t find an offensive-minded second baseman, please find an elite fielding defender.


I know you have a propensity to go with trades to get said upgrades, but frankly I think the minor league system is a little depleted at this point. If you are going to go the trade route, it’s probably better to trade high-upside players on the big league roster (sorry, Colby) rather than deal away prospects.

Don’t be afraid to go back to the bigwigs upstairs and ask for more cash to sign some free agents. Heck, it worked for the Red Sox; they opened up the pocketbooks the offseason following their own disastrous season, and look where they are now.

No, it’s not really the “Blue Jay Way” and that will likely mean overpaying any prospective free agents, but such is the cost of doing business in the landscape of the American League East today.

Another thing I fear is that Toronto is going to fall back into a less desirable free agent destination once again. Unless you’re planning on throwing a boatload of cash at somebody like Robinson Cano, I don’t think he’s ever coming to Toronto.

So here we are; another year, another unsuccessful season. Make that 20 years since the Blue Jays have tasted the postseason. There were sometimes when it hasn’t felt like it’s been that long, but this year it’s been painfully obvious this team fell well below expectations.

This offseason, more than ever, it’s crucial that things are done right. Sure, building a winner takes time, but people’s patience is growing thin. It should be made very clear at January’s State of the Franchise meeting where this team is headed in the near future.

Please, remedy the situation. Because the best way to help people forget the last two years (and even the last 20) is to make the Toronto Blue Jays a winning team again. 

Ian Hunter

Ian has been writing about the Toronto Blue Jays since 2007. He enjoyed the tail-end of the Roy Halladay era and vividly remembers the Alex Rodriguez "mine" incident. He'll also retell the story of Game 5 of the 2015 ALDS to his kids for the next 20 years.

9 thoughts on “An Open Letter to Alex Anthopoulos

  • August 21, 2013 at 3:25 pm

    "Dickey and Buehrle are essentially the only two who can be penciled into the rotation right now."

    What about Happ?

    • August 21, 2013 at 5:25 pm

      Don't worry, be Happ(y)

  • August 21, 2013 at 6:54 pm

    I think Happ is probably in there, but there are likely some questions about his health. Plus, if there's the opportunity to upgrade pitching, I say go for it.

  • August 22, 2013 at 4:40 am

    "No, it's not really the "Blue Jay Way" and that will likely mean overpaying any prospective free agents, but such is the cost of doing business in the landscape of the American League East today."

    Tampa Bay $57,030,272

    Toronto $118,244,039

    You were saying?

    • August 22, 2013 at 12:20 pm

      I should probably rephrase that … I think what I meant is overpaying is going to have to be the cost of doing business for the Blue Jays in particular. They don't boast quite the impressive farm system as the Rays, so they can't quite get away with just a $57 million dollar payroll.

  • August 22, 2013 at 6:12 pm

    It's never discussed, but the Jays would be a more popular free agent destination if they played on grass. Look what the turf did for Melky this year.

    • August 22, 2013 at 11:33 pm

      Fair point … I think AA even said a few years back that they tried to sign a free agent, but they wouldn't play in TO because of the turf. Rumour is it may have been Carlos Beltran.

    • August 23, 2013 at 7:21 pm

      Re-reading this, something else occurred to me. At the end of the 11 game streak in June, the Jays were actually a couple of games above .500 and clearly going in the right direction. At exactly that point, Reyes comes back and Kawasaki gets bounced to Buffalo. Then things start to go into the dumpster. Coincidence? No doubt, but I can't help but think of what Ferrell and Zaun had to say about the Jays as an organization a couple of days back. Replacing the overachieving Kawasaki, a guy who doesn't have the numbers, but always has his head in the game, with Reyes and his great numbers (and big paycheck) illustrates the point these guys were making. Did the switch make the Jays a better team, or did it undermine their sense of common purpose? No one on the outside can say, but, in hindsight, it does seem to be a pivotal moment How different 2013 might have been if the cohesion and sense of common purpose that were so apparent at that point could have been maintained.

    • August 25, 2013 at 4:56 pm

      I don't know if we can link the downfall of the Blue Jays being Reyes coming back and Kawasaki going down, but there's something to be said about team chemistry. I myself thought it was overrated, but perhaps not. The front office brought in a lot of players from different organizations, there was the World Baseball Classic, so they really didn't get all that much time to play together before the season started. Maybe that had a bigger part in it all than anyone could have imagined.

Comments are closed.